The Speaker

Chief John I. Dixon, III is past president of the National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives (NOBLE) and former Chief of Police for Petersburg, VA. Chief Dixon is one of the nation’s leading experts in community policing. Chief sat on President Obama’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. Born in New York City and raised in Philadelphia, Chief Dixon served with the City of Richmond Police Department for 23 years prior to accepting the post in Petersburg. Former Colonel in the U.S. Marine Corps, Chief Dixon is a results-oriented leader who is highly effective both within the police department and the community at-large. He is past President of the Central Virginia Chapter of NOBLE, chairman of the Corporate Sponsorship Committee and has garnered the respect of subordinates, peers and supervisors.

The Workshop

When Good People Write Bad Policy: Discriminatory Bans and Prohibitions Don’t Work : Wednesday, October 04, 2023 10:30A

Several states and municipalities are proposing to ban the sale of menthol cigarettes. Smoking is bad and tobacco kills in addition to the debilitating effects of nicotine addiction and need to prevent youth from smoking. Prohibitions and flavor bans have been spotlights in the national media. This proposal seems race-neutral. But over 85% of African Americans who choose to smoke prefer menthol cigarettes while most White tobacco consumers prefer unflavored tobacco. To draw up a ban only against products favored by people of color seems not only unjust but also remarkably insensitive. Giving officers even more reason to detain and engage on the basis of a flavored tobacco ban, including menthol, would assuredly lead to encounters that are likely to escalate to the unnecessary use of force, arrests, and possibly deadly force.

The unintended consequences of bans and prohibitions need to be better understood by public policymakers contemplating passing legislation that will directly impact the interactions between members of communities of color and law enforcement officers. This session will explore the laudable intent of the public health community to decrease the use of tobacco products by communities of color, address the serious concerns of youth using tobacco products, and how to stem the tide of youth use of e-cigarettes, and will expound on the lived experiences and expertise of leading Black law enforcement professionals on the unintended consequences of bans and prohibitions.